The views expressed on this blog are of the individual posting and are not official positions of the Mount Vernon Square Neighborhood Association (MVSNA)
Viewing By Entry / Main
Hide

ANC 2C Meeting Highlights


Advisory Neighborhood Commission 2C held the final meeting of its 2-year term tonight.

Douglas Development presented their plans for the New York Avenue project.  There were a few more renderings of the general massing, but not much more detail beyond that discussed at last month's MVSNA meeting.  The ANC voted to support the project before the Historic Preservation Review Board (HPRB) later this month.  A few additional tidbits:

  • They've worked out an arrangement by which they do not need to provide any residential on the site - the housing will be provided at St. Martin's in Eckington.  No zoning relief is needed.  
  • The 600 Block of L Street will have some retail dispersed between loading docks and garage entryways.
  • The Waffle Shop will relocate from Penn Quarter to the Mt. Vernon project.
  • They project 18 months to get through the historic, zoning, and permitting process before breaking ground.  Highest priority is starting the Square 450 West parcel which will have the greatest concentration of retail.  It will take 2 years to construct each portion of the plan (after approvals).  The different parts of the project may be constructed concurrently or sequentially depending on the approval process, market, and financing.

...At about this time, some hoodlum was stealing the back tire off my bike chained up outside the Kennedy Recreation Center within sight of the crime camera at 7th and O, but back to our program....

The Commission supported a Planned Unit Development (PUD) application for 625 Rhode Island Avenue NW submitted by United House of Prayer.  The new four-story building will have 16 apartments, 50% affordable (80% AMI), 11 parking spaces, and green space along the property.

The Commission supported a request by the new owners of 1612 8th Street NW to urge HPRB to approve a third story addition to their house.  The owners purchased the building, which had been condemned after 30-years of neglect, under the assumption that HPRB had allowed such additions for other houses on the block.  Even though the addition is set back 25 feet and is not visible from the other side of the street, because it is next door to a 1-story unit, the addition can be partially seen from one vantage point down the block.  The HPRB staff has therefore refused to support the application.  The owners expressed their distress at the lack of HPRB standards that go through proper notice and comment, and their level of discretion and willingness to invent new requirements as they go along.

The Commission voted in opposition to an application to rezone property on the 1800 Block of New Jersey Avenue from residential to commercial so as to allow locating a corner store there.  Commissioner Chapple expressed the concern of neighbors that they did not want commercial establishments on a block that has always been residential.  Chairwoman Brooks expressed concern that she had not seen written letters from residents expressing opposition.  I suggested to Chairwoman Brooks that the burden of showing evidence supporting an application for a rezoning is on the applicant, who had not had any communication with the ANC, to show support for the relief, not on the residents to oppose it.  The Commission voted to oppose the application, but I believe the vote was not unanimous.

Finally, Commissioner Padro announced that the groundbreaking for the new Watha T. Daniel Library will be on December 9 at 10:45am.  The public is invited to attend.

The community's thanks goes to all of the ANC Commissioners who have worked for us over the past two years. 

Long live my stolen bike tire.  Seized in the name of community service.

Comments
I was thinking, perhaps it couldve been a prank & was thrown in the bushes in front of kennedy rec.? might be worth taking a look.

Posted By Si Kailian / At 12/3/08 8:34 PM
Sorry to hear about your bike. Thanks for sharing the details of the meeting.

Posted By Paul / At 12/4/08 8:31 AM
This might sound snarky but several neighbors seemed to somewhat agree with Commissioner Brooks when she repeatedly demanded written opposition to the potential convenience store on the 1800 block of NJ. It seemed to be motivated by distrust of Commissioner Chapple. But did Commissioner Brooks get written support for Jemal's project in her SMD? and did she vote for it? I was tardy and missed that part.

Posted By Si Kailian / At 12/4/08 9:44 AM
Cary -- thank you for taking notes at this ANC 2C meeting and sharing your notes here.

I am curious about your statement regarding the New York Avenue project: "They've worked out an arrangement by which they do not need to provide any residential on the site - the housing will be provided at St. Martin's in Eckington. No zoning relief is needed."

What exactly does this mean? Is there some sort of arrangement (??) that Douglas Development has made that the St. Martin's Apartments in Eckington serves as an offset in order to justify the lack of housing on Douglas Development's site?

You may not know -- in which case I will follow up directly with Douglas Development. Thanks.

Posted By Scott Roberts of Bloomingdale / At 12/6/08 3:19 PM
Scott, yes, that's right. It's apparently called a "CLD," although I'm not sure what the acronym stands for or how it works. I wrote a bit more about it when Douglas Development met with MVSNA here: http://theother35percent.blogspot.com/2008/11/active-street-life-but-no-residential.html. I was surprised that such an arrangement does not require some sort of zoning relief to which the community would have a chance to weigh in.

Posted By Cary Silverman / At 12/7/08 5:09 PM
Cary:

Thanks for the link to your blog.

I googled CLD, zoning & DC and found a few hits.

CLD stands for Combined Lot Development. It sort of sounds similar to Transferrable Development Rights (TDR).

Here is a paragraph from a recent RFP for the 5th & I St NW site that briefly describes CLD’s:

Office of the Deputy Mayor for
Planning and Economic Development
Pre-Offer Conference Questions and Answers
5th & I Project
January 31, 2008

Q: The zoning requires a minimum amount of residential. How will the zoning issue be addressed for projects with no residential component? A: The Site’s zoning requires 4.5 FAR of housing. The housing requirement may be satisfied on-site or off-site through a Combined Lot Development (CLD). A project proposed for the 5th & I Site with no residential would have to satisfy the zoning requirement through a CLD(s). http://dcbiz.dc.gov/dmped/frames.asp?doc=/dmped/lib/dmped/questions__answers_from_pre-offer_conference.pdf


It appears that Douglas Development was able to satisfy a housing requirement for his New York Avenue project by participating in a CLD. I suppose that it is safe to guess that Douglas Development contributed some money to the 100% affordable St. Martin’s Apartments project in Eckington.

Your assumption may be correct -- a development team may get to use a CLD without any community input.

Posted By Scott Roberts of Bloomingdale / At 12/7/08 6:29 PM
It's as if we were talking about carbon trading here. But we're not. We're talking about pushing poverty from one neighborhood to another. In this case, Jemal is pushing MVT poverty to my neighborhood. Gee, thanks a lot. This is further confirmation that CCS and the city conspire to tear down old slums in order to build new ones. If the St. Martin's housing project turns into a problem property there will be plenty of fair warning.

Posted By Steve Rynecki / At 12/8/08 3:21 AM
Whoa, get a grip. Mount Vernon Triangle presently has hundreds of affordable housing units and will have WELL OVER a thousand before it's built out. So spare me rhetoric that our hood is just pushing poverty away.

Posted By Jason / At 12/8/08 5:03 AM
scratching the surface of st martin's
http://www.washingtoncitypaper.com/blogs/housingcomplex/2008/12/03/the-battle-over-st-martins-convent-why-preservation-doesnt-always-stop-development/

Posted By Si Kailian / At 12/8/08 10:59 AM


Blog software provided by Ray Camden